Kenneth Muir
The quality of the writing is wildly variable, which may be due to the translation. The world-building is excellent, and the sections of plot that take place within the Zone are imaginative and terrifying. This is the novel at its best. I found most of the characters to be extremely unlikable. It's difficult to root for anyone. Additionally, women have no place in this story other than as sexual objects or as tools for men to use. Perhaps this is a product of the era in which it was written. The novel spends much of its length on side plots or characters that are both uninteresting and inconsequential to the overall narrative. The plot ends rather abruptly and without any real climax, but I find myself appreciating the ending more the longer I mull on it. I do not regret reading it, but I will probably not read it again.
David Chick
Great beginning, great ending, but mediocre middle. I expected more adventures into the Zone, but from my recollection there were only 3 or 4. The book slows down a lot to highlight Redrick's tortured soul and while that is something worth exploring, it gets in the way of thrills. Probably just isn't my cup of tea...
David Hill
Roadside Picnic has a large, well deserved, cult following. The Strugatsky Brothers' fantastic imaginations are a rare find, and I've not read many stories with the same level of creativity. A lot of objects and questions go intentionally unexplained; the reader's imagination is part of why the story works so well. At other times more detail would have been helpful, but that's not a major concern. This is Soviet sci-fi at its best.
8 people found this review helpful