"Beautifully stark and bloody" - Heavy Metal Horror Hub
"Well executed and often just plain gorgeous" - Nerdist
"Good news, show fans: the first issue packs a big punch... It's abstract, it's gothic and it's fun." - Word of the Nerd
"For anyone who enjoys Gothic tales that cover every dark corner of the human, and inhuman, condition, Penny Dreadful is a pretty good bet." - The Pullbox
"Off to a great, mysterious start! Check this out!" - Sound in the Signals
"Filled with all the brooding, angst, misery and, yes, blood that you see in the TV show" - MCM Buzz
"Fantastic" - Adventures In Poor Taste
"Captures the spirit and essence of the show perfectly...4/5" - Nerdly
"I'm hooked, and I think you will be too." - Fellowship of the Geeks
"If you love suspense and/or horror, then this is definitely something you'll want to seek out." - Geeks of Doom
"Louie De Martinis¡¯ beautiful art is a perfect match for the story's Gothic influences. 8/10" - Flickering Myth
"9.5/10" - SciFi Pulse