Ritu Nair
I wasn't much impressed by the prequel novel, but I felt this one had some redeeming qualities, right until that ending. In this second book, Lara Jean and Peter are initially broken up (but were they even really together?) but she wins him back. However, before they can fully revel in their new relationship, a video of them in the hot tub goes online and they are basically a meme. Lara Jean feels humiliated and she pretty much knows it is Gen, but Peter just says that he will handle it and that it can't be Gen. Meanwhile, Lara Jean also has to deal with her insecurities - this is her first boyfriend, said boyfriend has baggage by the name of one vindictive ex, and there's also the fact that she doesn't know how fast or slow to let the relationship progress. You can see how it would feel for a teen girl like her to feel anxiety over so many things, but she tries to keep her chin up and get through it, let her life proceed normally, have awesome and heartening moments with her family, etc. Then comes John Ambrose McClaren - who sort of had a weird sidebar intro in the previous book. His entry brings back the nostalgia of their friendship in middle school, and for old times' sake, they engage in a game of assassin. Her interactions with him increase as their lives keep intersecting and she starts to like him, too. But she is still pretty much in love with Peter, who is starting to feel distant to her. Combine that with Peter being there on more occasions for Gen than for her, it is a recipe for disaster. I was leaning much into John for this book - he is so cute, and honestly a better pick than Peter, who keeps letting her down. He often acts jealous, even though he himself still keeps Gen in his life, despite her being terrible to Lara Jean. His priorities are also often messed up when it comes to which girl's feelings he should spare. He says pretty things, but his actions prove otherwise. While I would have normally said that these storylines made for a compelling arc, the truth is that it all comes down by the end. I felt that the violation of Lara Jean's privacy by that video wasn't given enough weight in the end, when it is revealed who did it. That person did not even show remorse for their actions, and instead blamed Lara Jean for a long ago slight, and Lara Jean even felt bad for it. I get a feeling that more often than not, Lara Jean is showing a doormat personality. There is being a nice person and then there is letting people walk all over you, and while Lara Jean shows a spine sometimes, when it counts she also backs down. The starting of the book was good, but then the ending ruined it and I was disappointed all over again. I am holding off reading the final book (because I want to get the last resolution to the story, whatever it is) until such time I feel less angry about the ending of this one.
35 people found this review helpful
Joanna Mejia
This series is so good. I loved both books and I cant wait to read the third book! <3 These books are seriously some of my favorite romance books. P.S. I still love you will make you want to be Lara Jean, she's so lucky because Peter loves her so much. You might cry in this book but its going to be worth it because in the end they end up together and you'll feel like your life is complete :,'D not really but still. The point is this book is GREAT and you should read it if you're into high school romance kind of stuff. ONE OF THE BEST ROMANCE BOOKS I'VE READ SO FAR. LOVED IT. <3 <3<3
35 people found this review helpful
Monserrat Gonzalez
I loved it , broke my own record reading it in less than 48 hours (there my weekend goes) I'm in love with Peter Kavinsky since the necklace situation. I think I could relate to Lara Jean in so many ways that it was probably the reason I couldn't stop reading. This was like eating candy in Halloween cuz you never get tired of it till it's over. Totally recomend this if you are in love with love.
55 people found this review helpful