Adam Tomkins
McQueen's attention to depth and detail amongst his leading cast is sadly undermined by some short sighted stereotyping and a surprisingly narrow plot. This account, however faithful it may be to real events, lacks any real dramatic development and it's linear sequencing relies heavily on careful cinematography to move it along. It only succeeds in its' efforts to animalise the plantation classes and humanise the slaves with violence. Some good performances but the script is bad and the story is dull.
Barrie Wright
A very good historically correct film depicting a part of the past that has still not being told fully,the actors put across the event's of those times with such energy and precision,you felt the blows as one of the slave's was beaten by the slaver, then buy the slave him self, how him self was mad a slave.Brad Pitt part was small but you could see how the American civil war came about, just listen to his character reasoning with the slaver as he tried to show him that what he was doing fundamentally wrong.
Andrew Shakespeare
All a bit clichéd. Whites can do no good. Blacks are all noble, thoughtful. I thought we'd left these PC stereotypes in the 1990's. A shame really. It could be a great movie, but the cardboard characterisations are rather tiresome and spoil things.
2 people found this review helpful