I really thought for sure that I would love this album. I really did. I love this band and I love all of their albums, and I loved all of the singles from this one, but, I don't know, it really doesn't do a whole lot for me. I was hoping that it would grow on me but it really hasn't. I feel like I'm trying to force myself to get into it, which bums me out. The lyrics and vocal melodies on a lot of the tracks feel a little undercooked and I think there are quite a few filler songs. Like I said, I am a huge fan of this band, but this album missed the mark on most points for me. I love all the singles and I like Toys alot and Queen of the Dark, but that's pretty much it. I really hope I end up liking it more.

Amazing album!!! This is Coheed at their finest! There's something for everyone on here. From the poppier songs to the heavier jams to the sweet ballad songs. I wasn't to sure what to expect because other than The Dark Sentencer most of the singles were kinda poppy but those were just warm-ups for the meat of the album.

After a brief conceptual detour with TCBTS, Coheed has come back to form with this new record. The announcement of a new 5 part album arc had to start somewhere and this album has delivered in so many places. It has some very classic C&C riffs and tunes throughout and plenty of songs with new direction and approach. Although most of the album follows a straight forward and basic ong structure, it delivers big time when that mold is broken. Could not have wished for a better start for their latest rock epics and look forward to more greatness.

I just saw them live where they performed Dark Sentencer and Unheavenly Creatures. Both songs are outstanding and if these are just the first two singles then the rest of the album will be phenominal.

This is a great album one of my favourites this year for sure. I'll be honest I found it hard to get into previous albums from the band bar a few songs but I love this one front to back.

This has been a rough year for me, one with a lot of heartache and sorrow, to the brink of the worst of these.....I have to say that Coheed and Cambria have brought a light back into my world, and one day, when all is said and done, I will be back to the man that I want to be. Thank you Coheed and Cambria for lifting me back up after all of my hardships.