Juan Pablo's season has been one of the most controversial and buzzed-about in the show's history. Viewers are locked in a heated debate about the handsome single dad. Many love this charismatic Bachelor; others are troubled about how he is treating the women. Tonight, the debate rages on as 17 of the season's most memorable women — including Andi, Cassandra, Chelsie, Kelly and her dog, Molly, Lucy, Renee and Sharleen — return to confront one another and Juan Pablo. So, what do the women really think of this Bachelor? Was he sincere about his search for a wife and stepmom for Camila? What about his kissing policy? And how do the women really feel about him sneaking off for a midnight swim with Clare? First, there is an update from the latest Bachelor happy couple, Sean and Catherine, and viewers will get a sneak peek at the season finale and the final two bachelorettes: Clare and Nikki.