Good Witch

As Cassie and Sam prepare to celebrate their first wedding anniversary, Cassie welcomes Grey House guest Joy, who seems to be spying on the Merriwicks. When Cassie gives Sam the perfect anniversary gift, Sam must quickly up his game – and must also advise Nick, who seeks a gift for his new girlfriend. Abigail and Donovan discover that the Heart of Middleton ruby is cracking, and that if it breaks completely, the Merriwick-Davenport curse will be permanent.

Cassie helps Joy mark her mother’s birthday by planting a tree and discovers a time capsule that Grace buried years ago. Sam competes against George, Adam, Martha, Tom and Stephanie in a chili cook-off, but has trouble locating his main ingredient – the paradise pepper. When George develops a roll of film from the time capsule, a moment Joy foresaw in a dream, a photo reveals that Cassie knew Joy’s mother.

Cassie, Abigail and Joy browse an estate sale, where Joy hopes to find a clock for Martha’s renovation. When charming Carter gets to the clock first, Joy makes a bet to win it back, putting her truck on the line. Cassie prevents Joy from using magic to win, and the two Merriwicks butt heads. Sam is inspired by a patient’s emotional support dog to start a therapy dog program at the hospital.

Cassie, Abigail and Joy revive the Merriwick tradition of making dream candles, which inspires Cassie to realize she’d like to teach. Abigail reveals her dream of living in Tuscany to Donovan, and he wonders if it’s compatible with his dream of being governor. Nick comes home under the guise of interviewing the Merriwicks for a school project, but Cassie and Sam discover that he really needs encouragement to complete a challenging physics course.

Cassie interviews to fill in for an art history professor. Abigail and Donovan realize that the diamond from the Middleton treasure may help break the curse and set out to talk to a cryptologist – only to discover another clue path when they break down near an old train station. Martha hosts her daughter-in-law, Claire, and learns that she’s going to be a grandma. The two women butt heads until they learn to embrace that they are both big personalities.

Cassie teaches her art history students a lesson on perspective with a trip to the museum. Sam successfully operates on Adam, but post-surgery one of Adam’s hands is slow to regain function. Joy dreams that Abigail and Donovan break up, and at first tries to stop it from happening – but then Joy and Abigail realize the break-up needs to happen, to slow the curse. Martha hosts a delegation from France, hoping they’ll choose Middleton as their sister city.

Cassie displays Nathaniel Merriwick’s paintings for Grey House’s 225th birthday celebration, inspiring Martha to direct a tableau vivant. Through the paintings and the tableau, Abigail and Donovan discover more clues about the traveler who helped set the curse. Sam challenges Adam to rehab his hand by appealing to his competitive nature at the foosball table. Cassie hosts influencer Hayley, who lives on her phone, until her reception magically goes haywire.

During a chocolate festival at Grey House, Cassie hosts Kenny ‘the chocolate king,’ whose big persona hides his insecurities about taking over the family business from his father. Sam meets Grant, the hospital’s new chief administrator, and they butt heads when Grant hires a surgeon without consulting him. Abigail’s friend Jason visits from New York, and when he proposes, it becomes clear that he’s under the spell of chocolates she made for him back in college.

When Cassie’s book club can’t see eye to eye, she invites her friends on a trip to Chicago to help them reconnect. Sam is called in to assist when the new surgeon’s techniques fall through. Joy wonders if she made the right choice partnering with Donna again as they work on Martha’s renovation together.

On Cassie’s last day teaching, she feels that she’s just getting warmed up. Sam is forced to take his unused vacation days, and he and Cassie meditate, putt, and sculpt their way toward finding a hobby they mutually enjoy. Joy hopes to stay in Middleton but has a big decision to make when Donna finds them a new job in Vermont. Martha smudges her new home in preparation for her housewarming gala but wonders if it worked when her best laid plans go awry.

The Good Witch may have met her match when Cassie’s long-lost college roommate, Autumn Delaney, makes an unexpected visit to Grey House. With an old score to settle, Autumn's on a mission to disrupt Middleton’s Halloween festivities… including their recreation of a historic 1890’s bonfire and their attempt at breaking the pumpkin carving state record of neighboring town Blairsville. As Cassie makes it her mission to restore harmony and happiness to their beloved Middleton, Martha accepts the challenge from Blairsville’s Mayor Davenport for the two towns to compete in a Halloween triathlon. Donovan’s looking to avenge Blairsville’s loss in last year’s Harvest Festival and will personally compete against Sam for Halloween glory. But it’s Donovan’s own wager with Abigail that proves all’s fair in love and Halloween. Through it all, Sam’s looking for the perfect way for he and Cassie to celebrate the most romantic time of year in the most romantic place of all… Middleton.