While Jordan is away at college, she receives a mysterious phone call, that lures her back to her hometown, only to discover that her aunt and sister, Ashley have mysteriously disappeared. Upon arriving home Reverend Michael, is there to greet Jordan. He convinces her to stay with her estranged father until they can find more answers. As Jordan begins to ask questions around the small town, she begins to unravel the truth about her mother's past, and the evil that has set its sights on her sister, Ashley. Will Jordan suffer the same fate as they did? It seems that only one that knows the truth is the small towns Reverend. Along Came the Devil II is the sequel to Along Came the Devil, which answers many questions about Ashley and her mother, Sarah.