TR “Smurf”
I realize some people would consider this movie almost like American propaganda, glorifying it's soldiers in war. The last scenes in this movie, about the funeral and procession, may reflect this aspect, yet I was left with mixed thoughts and feelings. First, he was a decent person, average good guy. During training in the army he is thought to hate his enemy, dehumanizing them, viewing them as "savages". Second, his loyalty to his fellow soldiers is so great, that he struggles to deal with those casualties who couldn't prevent; yet he acts with a certain discipline while on duty. When he goes back home, however, he feels he doesn't have a purpose, he doesn't fit in anymore. He is not able to find the person he used to be. This reminds me of the fact that almost all, if not all, soldiers are changed through war. War makes us less human. Third, some of the assignments he is given, along with his chosen way of solving them... in most cases using his rifle, gives me a feeling of less righteous warfare. This story teaches that war always becomes messy, with justice and truth among the first casualties...
1,015 people found this review helpful
Tonny Montana
En mi opinión la película fue muy buena pero el desenlace es demasiado abrupto y rompe con la acción de los pensamientos de Chris. A pesar de todo, recomiendo verla para sabernmas acercandenla historia de este héroe.
27 people found this review helpful
Dominique Charriere
The good American, the very bad "salvages", a Disney movie set in Irak. Eastwood is very very old, this movie is terrible to whoever likes History and Truth. Lena Riefenstahl or Eisenstein did much better works of propaganda than this mediocre one.
107 people found this review helpful