John Coryat
It's a confusing story with too many plot lines and too many distractions. The broken English of the actors makes the dialog seem forced. The overall premise is promising but unfortunately, the actual movie just doesn't make it. The movie does portray a rather grim and hopeless world of the USSR in the 50's. I'm glad I wasn't born in that part of the world. Overall, I would have to say it's a movie you can miss and really not shed a tear.
15 mense meen hierdie resensie is nuttig
Rob Turner
The fact that they spoke english in 1950s RUSSIAN story ( reminded me too much of the Tom Cruise flop Valkyrie where NAZIs spoke English well)was hard enough but this film failed at building any real emotional interest between the characters and the viewers. I wanted more than anything for this film to work but It didnt ever come together to form anything more than another bad attempt at trying to recreate the magic of a book on film.
4 mense meen hierdie resensie is nuttig
Barry Sumner
Reminded me of the malaise, wandering pace and style of Schindler's List, but not nearly as good of course. Plus, the two main plots work against each other, which begs the question, why is the banishment even necessary?