Xxaiden Knowlton
Although being basically an animated version of the story, and I mean word for word, I think a Christmas carol has a good mindset, but overall a only ok result. I was quite suprised for how dark the film was, but the story was quite scary itself. Jim carry plays an ok scrooge, although I don't get why you would cast him and not make him funny, but he's ok in this. Though not a bad film, an odd one to say the least.
Andy Dauer
Animation was beautiful but it was dark, too scary for young kids under 8, couldn't understand a lot of the movie due to their thick accents, some really annoyingly long chase scenes and super annoying ghost of present laughing obnoxiously too long and felt like the payoff at the end wasn't as uplifting as would've liked. Overall none of us enjoyed this movie much but I could appreciate the amazing animation and realistic looking scenes.
Nathan Murdock
I just gotta come right out and say that I've been putting off this movie for a long time. Sure I liked the book but I thought a weirdly-animated cartoon based on it would suck. But once again, Disney proved its worth. The movie is dark but not too dark, scary but not too scary, funny yet still retaining its dark and brooding tone. Most of the dialogue is from the original book and even though some scenes such as the dark horse chase is awesome yet unnecessary, this is one holiday movie that rocks!
27 people found this review helpful