Frances Acevedo
- Uygunsuz olarak işaretle
- Yorum geçmişini göster
This movie touched my soul. I was 13 years of age during the time of the
Vietnam War, without a care in the world . A few years later, some of the
friends I had grown up with, were drafted, and sent to fight in Vietnam as
well as a family member. Most of them never made it home and the few that
did, were forever changed. As for the family member, he was wounded 3
separate times, and sent home 3 times, but was unable to adjust. In the end
he took his own life. After viewing this movie thinking of the family and
friends I'd lost in that war and what they must have gone through , I cried
for days. Even now at times when I think of how our country turned their
backs on these soldiers, our fathers ,brothers, husbands, uncles, cousins,
friends who paid the ultimate price , I cry . I will forever remember and
miss them.
Harold L Hutchings
- Uygunsuz olarak işaretle
- Yorum geçmişini göster
This movie captured every nuance of the US Army as it really was better than any other movie I've ever seen. Surprisingly, it wasn't even about the Army. It was about life choices. Are you going to choose to do things by the book, or are you going to choose to be willing to do whatever it takes to go home alive, rules and morals be damned. Elias click versus Barnes click. It's interesting to note that neither went home alive and that sometimes it's hard to tell the good guys from the bad guys.
Chuck Kosack
If you want a great movie on Vietnam I recommend you watch "WE WERE SOLDIERS". Platoon is an aberration of the war, 15 year span of time in the time span of one movie. I served in Vietnam 14 months not as an infantryman but in the Signal Corp, but I saw more than I needed of "incoming" and death. No one can deny atrocities occured by our troops, My Lai is possibly the most horrible and widely known, but there were very few occurrences during the war by our troops. Another problem blown out of proportion is the drug use. It was there but drug use was much more prevalent in the military in other places, such as Germany and even the U. S., but it was not as sensational for the press.
43 kişi bu yorumu faydalı buldu