Mike Young
A classic western with some great character actors and the music alone sets it apart. The Seven Samurai did it better but it has the same mostly sad ending with pointless deaths (instead of heroic deaths) that pretty much sums up what violence comes too. But it mostly follows the myth of the west and many will like that. I'd rather see a movie depicting the west as it really was but for entertainment's sake it's a fun ride up to the anti-climatic ending. I'll still watch it just for fun's sake and you can't really go wrong with Steve McQueen. I still give it 5 stars.
Zyra L. F.
- Denunciar como impróprio
- Mostrar histórico da crítica
Horribly overrated remake of Seven Samurai, the only saving grace is the
incomparable Yul Brenner and underused Lee Marvin. Seriously, The Three
Amigos was a much better and entertaining remake of Kurosawa's brilliant SS
than the weak characterisations in this waste of 150 minutes. Also one of
the worst westerns I've ever sat through.
10 pessoas consideraram esta crítica útil
George Metcalf
Fantastic-There is nothing magnificent about these men. They are all losers in life. It is there deaths, and the reason for it, that makes them magnificent. They reach inside themselves for one final selfless act and check out heroes.
26 pessoas consideraram esta crítica útil