Jacqueline H.
- Означете како несоодветно
I'm sorry but this was an absolute atrocity. In my opinion, the only saving grace was Gary Oldman. Even then, this movie adaptation lacks everything that made the book so wonderful. The book was all about guilt, shame, hypocrisy, regret, etc. How guilt can actually tear some people up on the inside forcing an external yet hidden purge. A strong woman and a cowardly man.. This movie lacked everything...It was turned into a silly period soap opera.
Paul Nirenberg
- Означете како несоодветно
Simply put, while it stands as a fine movie in its own right, as an adaptation of The Scarlet Letter novel, it is simply terrible. Jaffe strips out all of the original themes of guilt and concealment in favor of an illicit romance. Frankly, the only thing this takes from the original novel is the names of the characters.
Sam Foster
- Означете како несоодветно
A poor excuse for a book adaption to one of the greatest novels ever written and a horrible film on its own.