Jon
Gritty and well written "super hero" movie. I put super hero in quotes, as most of the characters in this movie are really more like anti-heroes. Well shot, with a good soundtrack and for the most part great casting (silk spectre 2 is rough...) This movie is pretty faithful to the original comic aside from the ending which is different (and makes more sense). Overall this is a well written and acted movie that is fun to watch.
Jody Harris (imhavoc)
I never saw the theatrical release of this movie, so I don't have the reference of the version touched by a good editor. I only have this "director's vision" version, and it was horrible. I've also never read the graphic novels, and have no desire to after watching this disaster. Mostly, this was three hours of a director showing off what he *could* do and forgetting that he was supposed to be telling a story.
22 people found this review helpful
Scott J. Owens
I've always been dissatisfied, but overall enjoyed, all other Comic Book Flicks. The lack of physical reality - no blood, no gore, no back - stabbing human element; the political correctness for insuring a PG13 rating to insure maximum money making box office potential. ... Watchmen is the opposite of this. Finally, proactive & raw writing, vision & cinematic presentation unfold; I disnt want it to end! The Super Hero movie for adults. My all-time favorite comic book moving picture.
11 people found this review helpful