BJ McKay
I couldn't bring myself to care about the characters. To be fair, I don't really enjoy Kirsten Dunst in films for some reason. The storyline felt a little too obvious in the imagery (e.g., they're from two different worlds); I also didn't feel like I cared enough about the girl to go to the other world and risk everything for her. And the "earth-a matter burns when in contact with earth-b" thing made for interesting moments, but overall made some large plotholes that I didn't feel got dealt with thoroughly enough. They would have the worst ever-lasting-burning-sensations in that relationship. Ouch. That being said, really beautiful scenery, action-scenes, etc. Very fun visually.
Daniel Naslovar
A movie your gonna wanna add to your watchlist while it was a little slow, however the story was good, and the acting was good, had sad funny and suspense all in one shot. Easy 7