Following his arrest for allegedly soliciting a prostitute during his bachelor party, Nathan Connor asks his fiancé Janie Ross' ex-boyfriend, Peter, for help. Making it clear that the party wasn't his idea, Nathan insists on keeping Janie from finding out about his arrest. However, because there was also a fire in his hotel room that same night, he is facing serious jail time and it's impossible to keep Janie in the dark. But with her encouragement, Nathan turns down a plea bargain in order to prove his innocence. Meanwhile, when teacher Emily Claire asks for help after she's terminated for allegedly having sex with a student, Jared prepares to face his old high school headmaster, Walter Gallen. When the prostitute refuses to dispute the police report, Franklin & Bash's investigator, Carmen, gets the hotel security chief to testify that Nathan probably wasn't in the room when things got out of hand. But then the bellhop testifies that he overheard Nathan having what sounded like sex near the hotel pool. Confronted by Janie, Nathan claims that the woman at the pool was his assistant, Lauren Gonzalez, who he called for a ride home. After high school senior Chris Briggs says that Emily came on to him, a bartender tells Jared and Peter that this wasn't the first time Chris seduced an older woman. But the bartender refuses to testify before the school board. Jared tries bluffing, only to have headmaster Gallen claim that Emily has been accused of having sex with a student once before. With Pindar's help, Jared learns the identity of the other student. After Jared implies that he can undermine the kid's chances at being accepted to college, the student confesses to having made up the story. At the school board meeting, Jared engages the bartender in a successful effort to get headmaster Gallen to reinstate Emily in order to avoid adverse publicity. And, after Nathan's assistant Lauren testifies that Nathan only sought her advice because he was getting cold feet, Janie's testimony about the abstinence pact they made six months before the wedding convinces the jury of Nathan's innocence. But a new case is on the horizon when the body of one of Stanton Infeld's old friends is found, fifteen years after he disappeared during an ill-fated mountain climbing expedition. Infeld asks his nephew, Damien Karp, to find him a criminal defense attorney.