Alice (Jenna Elfman) has her life turned upside-down when she falls for the love of her life Ben (Stephen Schneider)— an adorable, quick-witted divorced father with three kids. But when she ignores her fears of commitment and her ability to mother, Imaginary Mary, her childhood invention (voiced by Rachel Dratch), comes back to life to express Alice’s deepest fears and add more chaos to the situation.
Alice and Ben agree that Alice should start sleeping over when the kids are there. Ben’s three kids seem OK with notion. In the end, Andy is the one most emotionally affected when facing the new family dynamic.