Rachel King
I really wanted to like this book but it turned out predictably in spite of multiple red herrings that could have lead to more interesting outcomes. The protagonist is wholly unlikeable in her blind, smug obsessinveness and bullheaded insistence that she's right. Other characters are flatly one-dimensional. Sadly, cannot recommend this one.
Friendly Neighborhood Inkslinger
'The Maidens' is the newest release from Alex Michaelides, bestselling author of the debut sensation 'The Silent Patient.' A psychological thriller housed within St. Christopher's College, Cambridge, the author binds mystery and murder to themes of classic Greek mythology. Told primarily through the narrative of Mariana, a group psychotherapist who's a year into mourning for her late husband, the woman is drawn back to the place where their love story began by what is quite likely the only thing that could motivate her to set foot there. A call for help from her niece, Zoe, regarding her best friend's murder. Drifting between the memories of their courtship haunting her still and the secrets stacking up around her that seem to be held tightly by both the students and faculty members, Mariana struggles to put the pieces together. Strangeness is afoot amongst a select group of students referred to as The Maidens and their darkly charismatic professor, Edward Fosca. From the opening pages, Michaelides captures grief exquisitely, affixing it to the page with the expertise of a collector.. as if it's a butterfly pinned neatly under glass for the rest of us to study. Above all else, it's the ability to convey those emotions.. so richly textured, that inextricably bound me to this story through its end. It certainly doesn't hurt that the author himself seems to be well-read. More than once, though I was loathe to put the book down, I found myself pausing in search of referenced writings that I'd never cared enough to read prior. His romantic description behind Tennyson's grief drove me to read the 3,000 line masterpiece, 'In Memoriam.' I researched theses for Antigone, dissertations on Euripides, and though Aristotle is one of my favorites.. this book had me viewing 'The Poetics' through a different lens entirely. Periodically, snippets of another narrative appear throughout the book. Snippets of what could be diary entries from an individual who has known great suffering and may in fact be inflicting the same on others. Interestingly enough, there are so many choices presented by the author, that it's difficult to even stick with a guess as to who it might be. Eloquently penned, the story moves at a steady pace, weaving.. labyrinthine through the lives affected by the murder. Those ripples reaching in some cases much farther than we might anticipate, creating more difficult situations on top of the first. Though Michaelides did keep me guessing to the end, my only complaint is that I felt almost cheated. I felt robbed of the moment where I might look back and say to myself, "I should have seen that," because it wasn't there. It wasn't just subterfuge and misdirection, it was a blank canvas. I like to call it the 'Saw' treatment.. and never have I been so infuriated by a film. Don't get me wrong, I loved the book. In a lesser writer's hands that feeling would have won out, but it's just so beautifully crafted and so emotionally driven.. that I forgive him for taking a path that just personally displeases me. I'm truly grateful for having read this story, I haven't been so immersed in a long time. If you like tense thrillers with a psychological bent and an elegant, artistic approach.. this is the book for you. (I received this title as an ARC. All opinions are mine and freely given.)
1 person found this review helpful
Leighton Books
Thank you to the publisher and BookishFirst for this ARC in exchange for an honest review! I was so excited to receive this ARC in the mail! Although I haven't read The Silent Patient, I have heard the hype. And, I know that literally everyone wants to read The Maidens. In fact, The Maidens might be the most hyped-about book of 2021. In my book communities, almost every single wishlist includes The Maidens. So when I got approved to review this ARC ahead of its release date, it was a dream come true. I couldn't believe it. Thank you again to the publisher and BookishFirst for this opportunity! The Maidens is a twisty psychological mystery that blends serial killer fiction with dark academia. The protagonist is Mariana, a therapist getting over the death of her husband. She gets caught up in a series of murders at a local college when her niece Zoe's best friend is murdered. Using her experience as a therapist and her intuition, Mariana realizes that the murderer is Edward Fosca, a popular professor of Greek tragedies. Suspiciously, he has a harem of college girls who follow him around, who he calls The Maidens. Here is an excerpt from the first page of the book: (This is not a spoiler, because it's on the first page.) "Edward Fosca was a murderer. This was a fact. This wasn’t something Mariana knew just on an intellectual level, as an idea. Her body knew it. She felt it in her bones, along her blood, and deep within every cell. Edward Fosca was guilty. And yet—she couldn’t prove it, and might never prove it. This man, this monster, who had killed at least two people, might, in all likelihood, walk free. He was so smug, so sure of himself. He thinks he’s got away with it, she thought. He thought he had won. But he hadn’t. Not yet. Mariana was determined to outsmart him. She had to." After I read this prologue, I couldn't wait to continue reading and see how the story progresses. I love books that are set in colleges, and I am also a fan of thrillers with twists, so I thought that this would become one of my favorite books. For a while, the plot was engrossing. I was voraciously reading every single detail and looking for deeper meanings. I was very interested and could not put this book down. I even finished it in one sitting. Unfortunately, the ending was a letdown. Without spoiling anything, I would just like to say that it didn't really make sense for me. Even though it was explained, I totally did not understand the motivations of the murderer for committing these murders. In addition, a lot of the themes and threads in the plot ended up leading to nothing. I had been drawn into every detail of the story, because I thought that the references to Greek tragedies were the author's way of communicating a deeper message. I was expecting a work of literature. It turns out that those references were just "window dressing," and this book is just a typical thriller. There's nothing wrong with thrillers, and I did enjoy reading this book. I do think it is being over-hyped though. Overall, if you enjoyed The Silent Patient or if you're a fan of thrillers and/or dark academia, then I highly recommend that you check out The Maidens when it comes out in June! Don't go in expecting a masterpiece of literature. If you go in with the mindset that this is a thriller, you won't be disappointed!
2 people found this review helpful