Dan Washbourne
A very unfortunate addition to a revered series. I'm not sure exactly how much of Rowling went into this script, but it's diabolical either way. The plot is absurd and runs contrary to established Potter lore, and the characters were knew and really cared about seem to do total personality 180s. Sadly, they're bound to just make another movie (or two!) out of this mess and the Harry Potter series will forever have it's own 'Phantom Menace'.
8 people found this review helpful
Meg Campbell
Full of plot holes and the unwelcome addition of some very poorly executed time travel. I think it had huge potential for exploring Albus' and Scorpius's time at Hogwarts, but unfortunately it read more like a badly written fanfiction. This did nothing for the otherwise amazing Harry Potter series, and I would rather pretend it hadn't been written.
2 people found this review helpful
Eloise Cato
An absolute ridiculous plot! So many holes, so many ideas rushed and jammed into one narrative! It was reminiscent of badly conceived fan fiction! JK has lost all notion of her characters- 'He who should not be named' getting his sexy on was, one, an undesirable mental image and two, not the actions of a narcissistic power hungry dictator- there is no way he would breed 'competition'!
4 people found this review helpful