Katherine Hall Page’s first mystery, The Body in the Belfry, won an Agatha Award for Best First Mystery Novel. The fifteenth in the series, The Body in the Snowdrift, won the Agatha Award for Best Mystery Novel. Page was also awarded the Agatha for Best Short Story for "The Would-Be Widower" in the Malice Domestic X collection. She was an Edgar nominee for her juvenile mystery, Christie & Company Down East. The Body in the Lighthouse was one of three nominees for The Mary Higgins Clark Award.