Things take a turn when Anthony rear-ends Maggie. He’s not nice to her and she calls him out on it. When he denies it, she challenges him to play Santa to prove that he’s not a Grinch. Maggie finds herself falling for Anthony as he steps up and is a great role model for her son. When Brody asks for him to be his dad for Christmas, Maggie finds herself struggling to give him what he wants. Will Maggie trust Anthony to step up as Brody’s father figure or will he continue to value his work more?