Lenore Kosinski
4 stars — You know what? This felt like a delicious guilty pleasure YA read. I’m a huge Broadway fan, so this was like bonus good for me — I loved the look into a new Broadway show. And not only that, but there were lots of references to other musicals, and it was just so much fun to watch both Jerzie and Zepp geek out about theatre. I enjoyed Jerzie’s voice — she was earnest, and nerdy, and both proud and humble. She pushed at her boundaries a bit, but in general was a goodie. She just felt real. I cringed when she tried to rebel, and didn’t quite get that as much — but I crushed right along with her, and went through all her ups and downs. Zepp was pretty fun — a bit cocky and arrogant, with his own issues he was dealing with in the background. I was surprised by some of his decisions, but he had his own growing to do. Usually I mourn the lack of dual POV, but I didn’t feel like the story was lacking without it. It really was more Jerzie’s journey. And they were pretty cute together, I have to admit. It just had all those things that suck me into a YA romance — lots of tingly tummy feelings, some drama, but all in all feel good. I will admit, sometimes it went in weird directions that I didn’t see coming, but nothing too out there. Lots of great secondary characters in this one. I loved Jerzie’s relationship with her brother, it felt real. Her Aunt Karla made me laugh and laugh at some of her quips. I loved that Cinny ended up being 3-dimensional. I wasn’t sure which way that would go, so I was super happy. Not 100% redeemable, but insight into the mean girl ness. And lots of other fun people in the background — mostly theatre peeps (and not just fellow actors). I enjoyed the musicality of it as well, even if it went over my head most times. And while it wasn’t a retelling like I somehow thought it might be (that’s on me, I’m an idiot), I still felt like we kind of got a bit of that too since they were putting on a diverse retelling. I really loved seeing how Robbie had reimagined the classic tragedy. Side note: While I’m used to ARCs needing a bit of clean up, this one felt a bit earlier draft than I’m used to. The bones of the story — plot, characters, emotions — were fantastic, and I was so in! But some of the writing was a bit awkward, and there were some inconsistencies. I sincerely hope that it got that final editing pass, because this story deserved the polish and shine. I think I was worried about this story, and it was all for naught. It had me smiling away enough that my hubby noticed, so definitely a success.