Melanie Monroe
Normally I am a fan of the Berenstain Bears (at least the old ones that I grew up with) but I'm NOT a fan of this one. The thing that drives me nuts is that sister just accepts everything mama tells her, and mama actually tells her very little. For example: sister asks mama how the baby gets out, mama doesn't answer that one, but passes it on to Dr. Gert. Dr. Gert says that the baby comes out through the birth canal, sister can't imagine it, but she can accept it - no more questions. I don't know about your curious youngsters but telling them something that they don't understand and can't picture doesn't do it for mine. Later in the story when mama and sister are walking home mama talks about the bees and how there are male and female flowers (which there are, but to be correct, more often one flower has both male and female parts) then she says how the bees collect pollen on their legs, but she never explains how the pollen fertilizes the pistil or how that would make a seed. But no worries, because "sister can accept that". Well I can't and neither do my kids. My child had more questions after reading this book than she had before... I encourage her to ask as many questions as she wants, but I had been hoping that this book would have answered some of the original ones she had. Overall, not a great intro to the birds and the bees. A much better, but still gentle version of the birds and the bees is the book: The baby tree... humorous, yet actually has some answers - not all of them, but some.
4 people found this review helpful