Michael Willis
I admire the undertaking that he and his brother tackled. What a feat, what a learning experience. I found the initial preparation, final packing, and departure for the trip, mixed with history about points on the trail very interesting. I was excited to start listening to the book. That being said, like a lot of the other reviews about ⅔ thru the book it takes a sharp DOWN turn. It was very hard for me to finish this book. In fact the last third of the book disappointed me so much that i’m writing this review, the first review that I have ever written. Knowing that the author narrates his own work, complete with mis-pronounced words, mis-characterization and misrepresentation, proves that if he would have done thorough research, (maybe speaking to someone with a little authority on the subject) someone would have set him straight. I am specifically speaking of 2 instance which take up approximately 1 ½ chapters of this book which include history of the Mormon faith and locomotives, both of which I am very personally familiar. Being ignorant with factual history and descriptions on these 2 topics makes me wonder if the other historical blurbs in the book, of which I am not too acquainted with, are accurate either. In the end Rinker comes off with an arrogant, “I’m educated, i’m smarter, and you're and idiot if you don’t believe and think the way I do” attitude. To use Rinker’s own words, just like one of his history flashbacks about a story teller on the Split Rock Ranch named William Frederick Cody or “Buffalo Bill”, Rinker Buck “has learned to capitalize, and prosper by exploiting the gullibility of the american people. Most of whom are so poorly read, so bamboozled by religion and the sensationalist mogul worshiping press, and so desperate for heroes that they will believe almost anything that a grand bullshitter like [Rinker Buck] shovels out.” In the end you need to leave a book like this feeling happy. Instead, you feel insulted if you have ever driven a minivan, believe in God, are an American, or an RVer. Stick with the real pro’s Bill Bryson or Hampton Sides, and stay happy.
7 people found this review helpful