Amy Weidenaar
I was surprised by how incredible this book was. American readers need to be aware that some words are spelled in a more European way. Depending on the age of the reader, you may want to explain to them that some words can be spelled two ways (color, colour) but it may not be the best idea to include the alternate spelling on a test. I hadn't read any of the previous works by this author and I feel a little cheated. There weren't any real "spoilers" for the kids but we were taunted with things like pirate ghosts. I want to read about pirate ghosts. There is definitely a larger arc to the story line that progresses with each book. We're shown that pretty clearly, but it doesn't seem that the books have to be read in any particular order. I would recommend it though. I'm going to go back and read them anyway so why not jump in at the beginning? There was fantastic information about the Underground Railroad as well as differences between the United States of America and Canada. Even as an adult, I found the information interesting. My daughter absolutely loved the book. Especially since the main character "October" was an outsider and considered to be a bit creepy. My kiddo hasn't gone goth yet, but she definitely loves things that fall on the morbid side. She just prefers them with a side of pink and lace. Lolligoth is her preference but sadly not featured in the book series. Overall, I think this book should definitely find its way into a classroom library as well as school libraries. Thank you to Evan Munday, ECW Press, and NetGalley for the chance to read this book and share my honest thoughts and opinions with others.