Paul Sadler
BOTTOM-LINE: Nice backstory, weak mystery . PLOT OR PREMISE: Jack Reacher is still in the military and gets transferred out of Panama just before New Year's Eve, 1989. The Berlin Wall is falling, Panama is heating up with Noriega, and Reacher is watching grass grow at his new post, until a General drops dead at a seedy motel. . WHAT I LIKED: The story gives more of Reacher's back story, and it is interesting to see the "man alone" working within a command structure with others. And it is an interesting premise -- what do you do in the military when the future looks like you're about to become obsolete? The supporting characters were good, and it was nice to see Reacher with his brother and mother. At the end, there is a twist about an error Reacher makes early on that comes back to bite him, and it is a great element to keep. The aftermath is kind of abrupt, with who went where and what happened next, but hard to avoid in a "flashback" style story. . WHAT I DIDN'T LIKE: The premise for the story is a little far-fetched, but when they get to the final reveal, the real specific motive is ridiculous as the people involved would never have done what they did, at least not on paper, and not openly. Reacher stumbles around in the dark long past where certain lines of enquiry should have been obvious, and particulalry for the identify of a specific witness. And the killer. . DISCLOSURE: I received no compensation, not even a free copy, in exchange for this review. I am not personal friends with the author, nor do I follow him / her on social media.
7 people found this review helpful
Jerry Burgess
As usual, this is another great Jack Reacher book!!! I'm reading these books in the order in which they were released. So, this book makes ABSOLUTELY NO CHRONOLOGICAL SENSE!!! This Should have been the 1st Reacher book, NOT the 8th! Another issue I'm having is that in ALL of the previous books he's addressed as "'MAJOR' Jack Reacher", not Captain! EXTREMELY poor choice in making this the 8th book instead of the 1st! You Should have, at least, made it seem like he was telling someone this story!!
13 people found this review helpful