
Tanvir Chowdhury
A truly incredible book chronicling an alternate world where the world developed around the East, not West. Kim has done an incredible job creating a flushed out alternate world, and their own versions of our history. My favorite parts of the book was the recurring theme of reincarnation and a "jati". Essentially a group who are destined to meet each other in each lifetime and influence the world and each other's lives. They may be reincarnated to different eras and cultures but they retain the same first letter of their name throughout the book. I personally find this idea incredibly romantic, as many times the characters will actually remember their past lives, reminisce and promise they will see each other again in the next lifetime, as in the book "to the next life, to a better time". I personally disagree that the ending was lacking, it really plays off the previous notion of the reincarnation theme. That no matter the time and era, these characters will find a way to each other, just like their previous lives. I'm a big sucker for themes like this. I won't spoil the rest of the book, its quite long but it's a thrilling read. This was my first book from Kim Stanley Robinson, and now it certainly won't be my last book from him Get this book, you won't regret it!

A Google user
I kept hoping that I would get into this book, but it never really happened. Character names were difficult to relate to, then once you became familiar with a character, the story would end and you would have to struggle to get familiar all over again. I guess "struggle" is the best description for me.

David Cooper
The book was well written and had a compelling story. Unfortunately, it meandered in the last hundred pages. Then it simply ended. In essence, the book was still telling it's main story up until the last two pages, which contained a very abrupt end.
4 people found this review helpful