Andrea Romance
In this book, the author uses the principles of natural selection to logically deduce what the characteristics of alien life might be: how alien life might resemble life on Earth, and how it might differ. I enjoyed those insights—they seemed sensible, enlightening, and persuasive. The book kind of fell apart for me at the end, when the author got into a philosophical discussion of whether intelligent extraterrestrial life should be considered "human." That seemed fairly pointless. The term "human" refers to our species, or more broadly, our genus. It's kind of like arguing about whether the term "dog" should refer only to Canis familiaris, or to all animal companions of intelligent species who join with them in cooperative hunting. At some point—most likely decades or centuries from now—we may be forced to confront the ethics of how to interact with intelligent alien life forms. For now, I think we'd be better off exploring the ethics of how we treat nonhuman earthly creatures that demonstrate self-awareness: apes, dolphins, and elephants, for example. The author touched on that question, but didn't seem to make a persuasive argument one way or another. That seemed to me a lost opportunity. It's a much more pressing question, especially given the endangered status of our nearest relatives in the animal kingdom. I care a lot more about chimps and gorillas than I do about hypothetical intelligent beings living light years away. Ultimately, this book is a thought experiment that invites us to think more logically and critically about the role of life in the universe. I hope it inspires people to think more logically and compassionately about life on our own planet as well. While it's important for us to explore other bodies in our solar system for evidence of life, it's even more critical for us to protect the species here at home, in all their diverse beauty. I hope readers go away from the book with that message in mind. Thanks, NetGalley, for the ARC I received. This is my honest and voluntary review.
1 person found this review helpful