
Dan Traina
I really don't care for the clip and save, choose and save, foundation of this rewards program. I would much rather just have a discount applied at the pump automatically. Marathon was always my go to fuel supplier. Because of the rewards program and how it's set up ...I actually just go to B/P now where I get a discount at the pump, usually three to ten cents off...a few times more. I guess it's just not for me...
1 person found this review helpful
Stuzo, LLC
January 7, 2026
We are sorry to hear that you did not have a great experience. We would appreciate your feedback to help us improve. Please email our team at support@marathonarcorewards.com or call us 6AM - 6PM ET 7 days/week at 855-920-3988 so we can troubleshoot your specific issue + help you earn and save!

Chad Portenga
- Flag inappropriate
- Show review history
Great rewards program, easy to use.(I even use it along with my Upside Rewards app and get additional savings!)For people complaining about it not showing the cents-off at the pump, it doesn't show it until you've swiped your card and picked your fuel grade. THEN it changes the price. My ONLY issue with the app is every few times, it forces me to log back in - it won't keep me logged in. Very inconvenient when you're in a hurry and have to log-in and do the OTP process again. PLEASE FIX!
12 people found this review helpful
Stuzo, LLC
December 15, 2025
We’re happy to hear that you’re enjoying Marathon ARCO Rewards! If you’re willing to tell us more about what we’re doing well or share ideas for what we could do better, please email our team at support@marathonarcorewards.com or call us 6AM - 6PM ET 7 days/week at 855-920-3988 to share your thoughts.

Buzz Cut
Good luck getting the offered discount!!! More often than not the rewards discount does not work at the pump. You put in your loyaly # and the price is supposed to be adjusted at the pump. Sometimes it worked before. Lately it hasn't been working, and you have to go inside to try to get the right price. This last time, the price didn't adjust at the pump (as usual), inside I was told to enter my loyalty # in store number after pumping, it didnt work, and I did not get the offered discount.
5 people found this review helpful
Stuzo, LLC
November 28, 2025
We are sorry to hear that you did not have a great experience. We would appreciate your feedback to help us improve. Please email our team at support@marathonarcorewards.com or call us 6AM - 6PM ET 7 days/week at 855-920-3988 so we can troubleshoot your specific issue + help you earn and save!